Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN Legal & Legislation

Missouri - Senate Bill 13 Reckless Lawsuit Preemption

Sunday, August 17, 2003

S.B. 13 aims to put an end to reckless lawsuits that seek to blame responsible, law-abiding firearms manufacturers and sellers for the actions of criminals. Over thirty states have already enacted common-sense laws to stop these lawsuits, and the Missouri General Assembly, the representative voice of Missouri citizens, voted overwhelming to enact S.B. 13 (the House of Representatives by a vote of 118-41 and the Senate by a vote of 24-9). Governor Bob Holden, however, vetoed the legislation. His reasons for disapproving of S.B. 13 are without merit. (Read Governor Holden`s veto letter here.)

S.B. 13 Blocks Suits That Seek Gun Control Through the Courts Rather Than the General Assembly

Since October of 1998, America’s firearm industry has been targeted by an orchestrated series of politically motivated "junk" lawsuits filed by 34 municipalities, including St. Louis, and by special interest groups. These suits seek to destroy a responsible American industry by blaming law-abiding manufacturers and sellers of highly regulated, non-defective firearms for the actions of criminals.

These suits are also an attempt by anti-gun interest groups to improperly use the courts to impose a failed gun control agenda, thereby circumventing Congress and State Legislatures. A Florida appellate court in upholding the dismissal of Miami-Dade’s suit against the industry had this to say:

The judiciary is not empowered to "enact" regulatory measures in the guise of injunctive relief. The power to legislate belongs not to the judicial branch of government but to the legislative branch.
(Penelas v. Arms Technology, Inc., 778 So.2d 1042, 1045 (Fla. App. 3rd Dist. Feb 14, 2001).

More recently, a New York appellate court, in upholding the dismissal of New York State’s case against the industry, warned, "that courts are the least suited, least equipped, and thus the least appropriate branch of government to regulate and micro-manage the manufacturing, marketing, distribution and sale of handguns." People of The State of New York v. Sturm, Ruger & Co., Inc., et al., 761 N.Y.S.2d 192, 199 (N.Y. App. Div. 1st Dep’t June 24, 2003) (emphasis supplied). "[G]iving a green light to a common-law public nuisance cause of action today will, in our judgment, likely open the courthouse doors to a flood of limitless, similar theories of public nuisance, not only against these defendants, but also against a wide and varied array of other commercial and manufacturing enterprises and activities." Id. at 196-197.

Lawsuits Already Proven Baseless Around the Nation

Governor Holden expressed an unwarranted concern that St. Louis’ case against the industry would be prematurely terminated before a full examination of the facts. Several other cities that have sued the industry have had a full examination of the facts, and case after case has been either voluntarily dismissed or thrown out of court by a judge.

  • Last year the City of Boston, after almost three years of exhaustive litigation, document review and sworn testimony from company executives, voluntarily dismissed its product liability and public nuisance lawsuit against the industry. Boston acknowledged in court that members of the firearm industry are "genuinely concerned with and are committed to, the safe, legal and responsible sale and use of their products" (emphasis added).
  • In March of 2003, a California judge, based on a full factual record, granted summary judgment for the industry and dismissed suits filed by 12 California cities.
  • In April 2003, after several years of litigation, the Cincinnati City Council voted unanimously (8-0) to voluntarily drop its lawsuit and instead spend the money on police overtime.

The overwhelming majority of courts that have addressed these lawsuits have dismissed them, saying that they do not state a legitimate legal claim against the industry. In the unlikely event St. Louis’ case is permitted to proceed, the city will see the exact same documents and evidence that Boston, Cincinnati, and the 12 California cities have seen.

The Courthouse Doors Are Not Closed to Parties With Legitimate Claims

In vetoing S.B. 13, Governor Holden asserts incorrectly that the bill will stop legitimate lawsuits. That is simply not true. Firearm manufacturers and dealers can still be sued under traditional tort law claims, like products liability, breach of warranty, and breach of contract. Injured plaintiffs - with legitimate claims - will still be able to seek redress for their injuries in court against the parties responsible under the law. A firearm manufacturer or seller that has lawfully sold a legal, non-defective product is not responsible under the law for the criminal misuse of that firearm, any more than a brewery is responsible for drunk driving accidents.

Without this legislation, reckless lawsuits will destroy the American firearm industry, rendering Missourians’ Second Amendment rights useless.

TRENDING NOW
Washington: Trigger Modification Ban Passes Committee

Tuesday, January 16, 2018

Washington: Trigger Modification Ban Passes Committee

Earlier today, the Washington state Senate Law & Justice Committee passed Senate Bill 5992 out of committee with a 4-3 vote. As drafted, this legislation has overreaching language that would ban modifications commonly made to ...

Eighteen States, Law Enforcement, Doctors, and Firearm Rights Groups File Amicus Briefs in Lawsuit Challenging California 10+ Magazine Ban

Tuesday, January 16, 2018

Eighteen States, Law Enforcement, Doctors, and Firearm Rights Groups File Amicus Briefs in Lawsuit Challenging California 10+ Magazine Ban

On Friday, January 12, several amicus briefs were filed in the NRA and CRPA supported lawsuit challenging California’s restrictions against magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds. The lawsuit, titled Duncan v. Becerra, challenges California’s ...

Democrats' Exciting New Hope Adheres to Tired Old Anti-Gun Dogma

News  

Friday, January 12, 2018

Democrats' Exciting New Hope Adheres to Tired Old Anti-Gun Dogma

Democrats searching for a standard-bearer in the 2020 presidential election lit on long-time entertainment, media, and publishing figure Oprah Winfrey this week, following a speech Winfrey gave at a televised Hollywood extravaganza.

Virginia: Gun Control Tops New Governor’s Agenda

News  

Friday, January 12, 2018

Virginia: Gun Control Tops New Governor’s Agenda

This week, Virginia Governor McAuliffe and Governor-Elect Ralph Northam outlined their top priorities for the upcoming legislative session, and highlighted expanded background checks for all firearm sales and other transfers (so-called “universal” background checks) as ...

Indiana: Gun Bills Filed

Saturday, January 13, 2018

Indiana: Gun Bills Filed

With the 2018 Indiana legislative session underway, a number of bills affecting your Second Amendment and hunting rights have been filed.

Washington: CPL Permit Confidentiality Bill Introduced

Wednesday, January 17, 2018

Washington: CPL Permit Confidentiality Bill Introduced

Last week, Washington legislators introduced an NRA-backed bill to protect the private, personal information of Washington's concealed pistol license holders from public records requests.  Senate Bill 6173, sponsored by Senator Dean Takko (D-19), and House Bill ...

Washington: Senate Law & Justice Committee to Hear Anti-Gun Bills Next Monday

Wednesday, January 10, 2018

Washington: Senate Law & Justice Committee to Hear Anti-Gun Bills Next Monday

On Monday, January 15th at 10:00AM, the Senate Law & Justice Committee is scheduled to hear multiple anti-gun bills.  Testimony will be limited during the hearing, so all NRA members and Second Amendment supporters are strongly ...

Washington: House Judiciary to Hear Gun Control Bills

Thursday, January 18, 2018

Washington: House Judiciary to Hear Gun Control Bills

On Thursday, January 25th at 1:30PM, the House Judiciary Committee is scheduled to hear several sweeping gun control bills.  NRA Members and Second Amendment supporters are strongly encouraged to attend the committee hearing to voice your opposition ...

Washington: Substitute Versions of Gun Control Bills to Be Heard

Saturday, January 13, 2018

Washington: Substitute Versions of Gun Control Bills to Be Heard

Last night, anti-gun legislators introduced substitute bills for Senate Bill 5444 and Senate Bill 5463.  These substituted versions will replace the original bills that are scheduled for a public hearing on Monday, January 15th. NRA remains opposed ...

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

Gun Laws  

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

CAUTION: Federal and state firearms laws are subject to frequent change. This summary is not to be considered as legal advice or a restatement of law.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -
NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.