Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

Burlington Police Chief Puts New York Politicians Before Vermonters

Thursday, December 7, 2017

Burlington Police Chief Puts New York Politicians Before Vermonters

As H.R. 38, the Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act of 2017, comes closer to becoming law, the arguments against the legislation are increasingly strained. There are disingenuous appeals to federalism by those who would happily burden firearms owners under any number of federal gun control schemes. Despite Right-to-Carry permit holders’ sterling record as one of the country’s most law-abiding demographics, lawmakers fear monger about the purported dangers of letting these virtuous Americans exercise their rights in Times Square. 

Perhaps inspired by these efforts, on November 29, Burlington, Vt. Police Chief Brandon del Pozo, - a Brooklyn native, Dartmouth and John F. Kennedy School of Government alumnus, former NYPD deputy inspector, and self-described “political philosopher” - offered the stupidest argument against Right-to-Carry reciprocity to date. According to del Pozo, the legislation would prompt criminals to establish residency in the Green Mountain State so that they may carry throughout the country, ostensibly out of their thoughtful concern for pursuing their violent criminal activities in the most law-abiding manner possible.

The chief’s comments were made at a press conference organized by the anti-gun “Prosecutors Against Gun Violence.” Photos from the event featured del Pozo alongside Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance Jr. and Los Angeles City Attorney Mike Feuer.

Vermont is the original constitutional, or permitless, carry state. Chapter 1 Article 16 of the Vermont Constitution makes clear that “the people have a right to bear arms for the defence of themselves and the State.” Vermont statute only prohibits, carrying a firearm “openly or concealed, with the intent or avowed purpose of injuring a fellow man.”

Vermonters’ Right-to-Carry without first obtaining government permission was affirmed in the 1903 case of State v. Rosenthal, where a plaintiff challenged a local ordinance that prohibited the carrying of pistols, among other items, within the city without the express approval of the mayor or chief of police. The Vermont Supreme Court determined that the ordinance was “so far as it relates to the carrying of a pistol… inconsistent with and repugnant to the Constitution and the laws of the state” and therefore void. 

How has this liberal carry regime worked for the Green Mountain State? According to the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting data, in 2016 Vermont was second only to fellow constitutional carry state Maine for the lowest violent crime rate in the nation. The vibrant and responsible gun culture in these states is a living testament to the absurdity of gun control supporters’ core contention that more guns and less restrictive gun control regimes lead to more violence.

As a result of this deep-rooted respect for gun rights, Vermont has never instituted a concealed carry licensing scheme. Anyone who is not prohibited from possessing firearms under Vermont or federal law may exercise their Right-to-Carry regardless of whether they are a resident of the state. The small downside is that Vermont residents cannot currently enjoy the benefits of Right-to-Carry reciprocity with other states by obtaining a Vermont-issued carry permit. Of course, Vermonters may obtain a carry permit issued by another state for purposes of reciprocity.

Vermonters only stand to gain from H.R. 38. Vermont already recognizes the rights of all law—abiding non-residents to carry for self-defense, and the legislation would create the opportunity for Vermonters to be able to carry throughout the country. The politicians and officials from Vermont, other permitless carry states, and states with outright recognition of other permits, that oppose HR. 38 are merely restricting the rights of own constituents with no reasonable justification.

As for the growing list of unreasonable justifications, according to an account from the VTDigger, “del Pozo said it would be relatively easy for people who wish to carry guns across state lines to establish residency in Vermont.” The chief explained, “Imagine you’re a person who has the opportunity to engage in criminal activity by carrying a concealed weapon legally anywhere in the country…Permitless states like Vermont will be exploited to the detriment of public safety of everyone else.”

Set aside for a moment the absurdity of the notion that those intent on using firearms to commit criminal violence would give any thought to complying with the legal rubric established under H.R. 38.

In order to carry in other states under this bill, Vermonters would be required to hold “a valid identification document containing a photograph.” To establish residency sufficient to obtain a Vermont–issued driver’s license or other photo identification card from the Vermont Department of Motor Vehicles, an individual “must provide the Department with two pieces of mail with their current name and street address.”

The current valid street address requirement is stringent. An individual that receives mail at a PO Box must provide one of the following:

Utility bill (must list service address)
Residential property tax bill (with physical location)
Vermont Tax Form LC-142 (Landlord Certificate)
Vermont EBT or Vermont AIM identification card
Homeowners/Renters insurance (policy/proof of claim)

Alternatively, a “parent, legal guardian, homeowner, leaseholder” can attest to an individual’s residency by providing documentation of their residency and submitting a signed affidavit vouching for the applicant. Applicants must apply for a Vermont identification card in-person at the DMV. Further, establishing Vermont residency could impact the legal status, benefits, and services an individual enjoys in the state where they actually reside.

Del Pozo’s suggestion that H.R. 38 will prompt felons to invade the pastoral communities of the Green Mountain State to receive mail at phony street addresses and then wait in line at the DMV so that they might more lawfully wreak criminal havoc throughout the country is laughable. The chief’s behavior is so at odds with the interest of Vermonters that it should prompt some to question whether this flatlander works on behalf of his constituents, or is more concerned with pleasing out-of-state interests, such as his wealthy former master, gun control financier and former-New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg. At the Kennedy School of Government they call this a principle-agent problem.

TRENDING NOW
Shoddy Science and Shaky Assumptions: Court Invalidates California’s Handgun Ad Ban on First Amendment Grounds

News  

Friday, September 21, 2018

Shoddy Science and Shaky Assumptions: Court Invalidates California’s Handgun Ad Ban on First Amendment Grounds

Earlier this month, a federal court invalidated California’s ban on premises advertising relating to handguns (but not other firearms), disparaging the state’s proffered justification for the law as nothing more than “mere speculation and conjecture.” 

New Industry Statistics Underscore Popularity of “America’s Rifle”

News  

Friday, September 21, 2018

New Industry Statistics Underscore Popularity of “America’s Rifle”

Senator Dianne Feinstein has spent the last 26 years pushing gun control at the federal level and earlier this month demonstrated her willingness to distort facts and Supreme Court precedent in her ongoing effort to ...

Outrageous! NC University Forces Student to Remove NRA Flag from Dorm Window

News  

Wednesday, September 19, 2018

Outrageous! NC University Forces Student to Remove NRA Flag from Dorm Window

Elon University student forced to remove NRA banner from his dorm room window.

Bloomberg Presidential Run? Maybe. Bloomberg Effort to Buy the Midterms? Definitely.

News  

Friday, September 21, 2018

Bloomberg Presidential Run? Maybe. Bloomberg Effort to Buy the Midterms? Definitely.

Billionaire gun control financier and former-New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg is once again floating a presidential run.

Gun Control Twist: Saving One Life “Does Not Justify” Right-to-Carry

News  

Friday, September 21, 2018

Gun Control Twist: Saving One Life “Does Not Justify” Right-to-Carry

Gun control advocates often use some version of the phrase “if it saves one life” in order to justify their ineffective proposals. This week, the anti-gun editorial page of the Chicago Sun-Times offered a different ...

Levi’s Teams with Billionaire Michael Bloomberg to Attack Gun Rights

News  

Friday, September 7, 2018

Levi’s Teams with Billionaire Michael Bloomberg to Attack Gun Rights

Levi Strauss & Co. established its brand in the mid-19th century by selling durable clothing to working-class Americans. As Levi’s signature jeans gained popularity amongst a wider set in the middle of the last century, ...

Anti-gun Senator Accompanied by “Unprecedented” Security Detail While Traveling in California

News  

Friday, September 14, 2018

Anti-gun Senator Accompanied by “Unprecedented” Security Detail While Traveling in California

Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) is no fan of the Second Amendment. As California attorney general, she sided with local officials who refused to issue concealed carry permits to qualified, law-abiding applicants unless they could demonstrate an extraordinary ...

NRA Calls on Phil Bredesen to Retract Misleading Ad

News  

Wednesday, September 19, 2018

NRA Calls on Phil Bredesen to Retract Misleading Ad

The National Rifle Association Political Victory Fund today called on U.S. Senate candidate Phil Bredesen to retract a false and misleading campaign ad where he cites an incorrect NRA grade and misleads voters by claiming ...

Gun Control Activist Urges Canadian Audience to Get Involved in U.S. Politics

News  

Friday, September 14, 2018

Gun Control Activist Urges Canadian Audience to Get Involved in U.S. Politics

For someone who has previously falsely accused the NRA of funneling foreign money into domestic politics, it must be that David Hogg either forgot he was in Canada recently or failed to appreciate that it’s also illegal ...

News  

Wednesday, September 19, 2018

NRA Endorses Marsha Blackburn for U.S. Senate

On behalf of our six million members across the country, the National Rifle Association Political Victory Fund (NRA-PVF) today endorsed Marsha Blackburn for U.S. Senate in Tennessee.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.