Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN Legal & Legislation

Ninth Circuit Holds that Second Amendment Protects the Right to Acquire Firearms

Monday, May 23, 2016

Ninth Circuit Holds that Second Amendment Protects the Right to Acquire Firearms

On Monday, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that the right to keep and bear arms necessarily includes the right to acquire them.  The case, Teixeira v. County of Alameda, involves a challenge to an Alameda County zoning ordinance that prohibits gun stores from operating within 500 feet of a residentially zoned district.  

The plaintiffs in the case wished to open a gun store that was 446 feet away from the nearest residential property and was also separated from the residences by a major interstate highway.  Because of the intervening highway, the county zoning board initially awarded a variance to the 500-foot rule, but the variance was revoked after a successful appeal by a local homeowners’ association that included members who “are opposed to guns and their ready availability and therefore believe that gun shops should not be located within [their] community . . . “  

While basic logic seems to demand that the right to keep and bear arms would be hollow without the right to acquire them, the county nonetheless argued against the existence of a right to acquire arms by defending its ordinance. 

While basic logic seems to demand that the right to keep and bear arms would be hollow without the right to acquire them, the county nonetheless argued against the existence of a right to acquire arms by defending its ordinance.  In making this argument, the county relied on a single line from the Supreme Court’s decision in District of Columbia v. Heller.  That line provides that “nothing in [the] opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding . . . laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms.”  Again, it shouldn’t take a law degree to understand that an ordinance that prohibits any new gun store from opening within a county is neither a “condition” nor a “qualification” on the commercial sale of arms because a “condition” or “qualification” would require that commercial sales were actually taking place.  Unfortunately, the lower court accepted this illogical argument with little explanation for how its decision complied with the Second Amendment.  

The Ninth Circuit overruled the lower court on Second Amendment grounds after conducting a thorough historical analysis and finding no evidence to support the county ordinance as the type of “longstanding” law mentioned in Heller.  The court even cautioned the lower court that if the ordinance truly has the effect of prohibiting new gun stores within the county, that the lower court must apply something akin to the highest level of judicial scrutiny, which the ordinance would almost certainly fail.  

While the case is far from over for the plaintiffs, as they must now go back to have their case heard in the lower court, the decision currently stands as one of the few opinions to expressly recognize the right to acquire firearms and the corresponding right to sell them.  This case also serves as just one more example of the seemingly endless lengths that anti-gun advocates will stretch the law to defend their overbroad and ineffective gun-control laws.   

 

IN THIS ARTICLE
Second Amendment Legal
TRENDING NOW
Obama Lies about Guns… Again

News  

Friday, June 14, 2019

Obama Lies about Guns… Again

Despite no longer living in the White House, former President Barack Obama continues to be a headache to law-abiding Americans. On May 30, Obama spoke at a digital innovation event in Brazil. During the onstage ...

Don’t Say They Didn’t Warn You: Left Leaning Voices Question Democrats’ Anti-Gun Proposals, Fervor

News  

Friday, June 7, 2019

Don’t Say They Didn’t Warn You: Left Leaning Voices Question Democrats’ Anti-Gun Proposals, Fervor

If the 2020 Democrat presidential primary is any indication, that party’s base and donor class will accept nothing less from their nominee than commitments to sweeping gun control. And the contenders appear happy to accommodate ...

Pittsburgh Mayor Presents DICK’S CEO an Award for Gun Control Advocacy

News  

Friday, June 14, 2019

Pittsburgh Mayor Presents DICK’S CEO an Award for Gun Control Advocacy

On June 4-5, the annual Yale Mayors College & CEO Summit was held in New York City. The theme of this year’s CEO Summit was “Trumpeting the Issues without Becoming the Issue: Selective Use of CEO Voice.” ...

Advice Columnist Tells Father to Evict Daughter from His House for Owning a Gun

News  

Friday, June 14, 2019

Advice Columnist Tells Father to Evict Daughter from His House for Owning a Gun

Amy Dickinson is an advice columnist who, according to the company that syndicates her work, “combines storytelling with advice that is rooted with honesty and trust.” “Ask Amy” appears in newspapers that include The Baltimore Sun, ...

Tennessee: Governor Bill Lee Signs Self-Defense Legislation into Law

Wednesday, May 29, 2019

Tennessee: Governor Bill Lee Signs Self-Defense Legislation into Law

Last week, Governor Bill Lee signed important self-defense legislation, House Bill 1264 /Senate Bill 705, into law.

Bloomberg Course: Ineffective Policies and Non-Existent Technology

News  

Friday, June 14, 2019

Bloomberg Course: Ineffective Policies and Non-Existent Technology

This week in the online course “Reducing Gun Violence in America: Evidence for Change” is a real rollercoaster. Week Five is titled “Regulating Gun Design, Enforcing Gun Laws, and Reducing Police-Involved Shootings” covers so-called assault ...

New Jersey “Smart Gun” Law Gets an F Grade

News  

Friday, June 14, 2019

New Jersey “Smart Gun” Law Gets an F Grade

After signing six gun control measures into law a year ago, New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy warned that “Our work is far from done.” Several new bills are now making the rounds in a state already notorious ...

Nevada: Gov. Sisolak Signs Anti-Gun Bill

Friday, June 14, 2019

Nevada: Gov. Sisolak Signs Anti-Gun Bill

Ignoring the constitutional rights of law-abiding Nevadans, on June 14th, Governor Steve Sisolak signed omnibus anti-gun Assembly Bill 291 into law.  Your NRA would like to thank the many lawmakers who stood with our members and ...

Nevada: Deadline Tomorrow For Governor to Act on Anti-Gun Bill

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Nevada: Deadline Tomorrow For Governor to Act on Anti-Gun Bill

Tomorrow, June 14th, is the deadline for Governor Steve Sisolak to take action on Assembly Bill 291. 

Does a Suppressed Pistol Sound like a Nail Gun?

News  

Friday, June 7, 2019

Does a Suppressed Pistol Sound like a Nail Gun?

In response to reports that the Virginia Beach shooter used a firearm suppressor in carrying out his terrible crime, David Chipman, Senior Policy Advisor for the Giffords gun control group, claimed that a suppressed pistol ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.