Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Big Government Provides Some Data

Tuesday, September 7, 2021

Big Government Provides Some Data

The FBI usually released crime data in September. Researchers and policy wonks would pour over the data, looking for any hint of a chance for a policy intervention or investigating long-term trends. This year will be different. The FBI announced in 2015 that the underlying reporting system for crime data would change by 2021 but not all agencies nationwide are quite ready for the new system. Implementation remains a work in progress. 

The Uniform Crime Report was conceived in the 1920s and formally launched in 1927 under the Committee on Uniform Crime Reporting. Responsibility for the collection and reporting of data was delegated to the FBI three years later, in 1930. For 90 years, not much changed. The new system, incident based reporting, promises to be a better and more accurate system than what sufficed for ninety years. The National Incident Based Reporting System (NIBRS) reports up to ten offenses within each incident, while the current system only reports the most egregious crime.

For example, consider a robbery that ends in murder. Under the old system, only murder would be reported in the annual crime tally. The new system promises the capability to report both the robbery and the murder.

The current hang-up is that the old system really isnt the old” system. Only 57% of law enforcement agencies in the country are participating in NIBRS as of September 2, 2021, though the deadline for switching to NIBRS was January 1, 2021. The change was announced in 2015.

Five states are not yet certified in NIBRS, meaning they do not (yet?) have the technical infrastructure in place to support the new reporting system. Five out of 50 isnt bad, right? These states are Alaska, California, Florida, New Jersey, and New York – representing a sizeable chunk of the total population. That does not include Alabama, which has no state program, or the eighteen states with less than a majority of their law enforcement agencies participating.

This is data that law enforcement agencies should have on hand. Its crime data. States have had at least six years to develop the new capabilities, and law enforcement agencies capture the data by the very nature of their work. It is their work.

The difficulties with NIBRS dont end with low participation. Counting multiple offenses within a single incident will naturally lead to higher crime totals. Any comparison of data aggregated in this manner compared to the single-offense tally system will look like a spike in crime. The spike will, of course, simply be the new parameters in effect.

We saw this effect when the FBI changed the definition of rape years ago. The change limited the ability to trend that crime, particularly at the state level.

We may see similar difficulties trending NIBRS data, though the FBI has said it will continue to convert NIBRS data to the old format for this purpose through the transition period. We do not yet know how long the transition period will last. Once the definition or parameters change, trending becomes much more difficult. Well either default to the old system through conversions, or force two incompatible data collection methods together.

Its too early to say that the FBI has botched the new system. It may very well be useful; it certainly has promise – provided participation increases. The FBI has rolled out a very shiny data exploration tool, though it does not lend itself easily to state-to-state comparisons. Our own NRA-ILA crime data tool goes back to 1960 and specifically allows state-to-state comparisons. Its at the bottom of this fact sheet about crime. All of the data is from the FBI, but its simpler than the FBIs tool.

Isnt that what we all want – simple? We expect the FBI, state, and local law enforcement agencies to know how much crime happened in their jurisdiction – or, at least how much crime was reported to law enforcement in their jurisdictions. The FBI is in the 91st year of managing national crime data, and five years has not been enough time to get the well-publicized new system fully operational.

This is a recurring problem with the federal government. Remember, the CDC annually published absurd estimates on non-fatal gunshot injuries up until they were called out publicly by The Trace. The CDC has since ceased providing that estimate entirely, though anti-gun researchers continued to cite the ridiculous number long after the hopelessly flawed methodology was exposed.

Hospitals know the reasons for their patientsvisits, and law enforcement agencies are aware of the crime reported to them. Why does the federal government have such difficulty aggregating and reporting this data? Researchers and politicians rely on this data to understand the world and develop policy. Anti-gun activists – including those masquerading as earnest researchers – have shown themselves willing to misconstrue data to advance their cause, and this new data system may offer them just such an opportunity. Its all too easy to see activists comparing incompatible data points without offering a disclaimer.

Before essentially getting its own house in order with basic data collection, anti-gun politicians in Congress and unelected bureaucrats want the federal government to fund research projects. That funding has gone to well-known and well-funded anti-gun research programs and professors at universities with multi-billion-dollar endowments.

Maybe – just maybe – the federal government should focus on getting the data right. Publishing research is far more advantageous to the anti-gun agenda than simply collecting the right data, but wed all like to live in a country in which government bureaucrats are not actively seeking to infringe on Constitutional rights.

IN THIS ARTICLE
FBI National Crime Report
TRENDING NOW
Biden Administration Finalizes “New” Firearm Storage Rule

News  

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Biden Administration Finalizes “New” Firearm Storage Rule

On January 3, the Biden Administration’s Department of Justice (DOJ) announced that it would be finalizing a new rule on firearm storage for Federal Firearm Licensees (FFLs). The DOJ additionally announced an update to the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, ...

Washington: Another Year – Another Extreme Gun Ban!

Friday, January 14, 2022

Washington: Another Year – Another Extreme Gun Ban!

The legislature only just gaveled in this week and anti-gun legislators and gun control groups couldn’t wait to reintroduce their extreme gun ban legislation - an "assault weapons" ban, Senate Bill 5217.

Washington:  The Hits Keep on Coming as Magazine Ban Pulled to the Senate Floor

Friday, January 14, 2022

Washington: The Hits Keep on Coming as Magazine Ban Pulled to the Senate Floor

On Friday, the Washington Senate pulled magazine ban legislation, Senate Bill 5078 to the Senate Floor where it is eligible for a vote for passage.

Growing the Gun Community in Unlikely Places

News  

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Growing the Gun Community in Unlikely Places

We mentioned a Beverly Hills gun shop last week in an article about the continued increase in background checks and gun sales. We spoke with the proprietor of that shop, and he offered a very humanized ...

Chicago Politicians, Whistling Past the Graveyard

News  

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Chicago Politicians, Whistling Past the Graveyard

It’s no secret that crime in Chicago has reached levels not seen in decades. Crime statistics released by the Chicago Police Department (CPD) for October 2021 show significant increases in incidents of serious crime compared to the ...

Anti-gunners Ignore the Obvious, Lamely Try to Blame Gun Sales for Rise in Homicide Rates

News  

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Anti-gunners Ignore the Obvious, Lamely Try to Blame Gun Sales for Rise in Homicide Rates

Last week, two gun control advocates – who described themselves as a “crime analyst” and a “data scientist” -- published an article in the anti-gun publication The Atlantic blaming the 2020 spike in homicide rates on that ...

Alabama: Sheriff’s Association Working With Anti-Gun Group Opposing Constitutional Carry

Monday, January 17, 2022

Alabama: Sheriff’s Association Working With Anti-Gun Group Opposing Constitutional Carry

Bobby Timmons, director of the Alabama Sheriff’s Association (ASA), is so opposed to acknowledging your inherent right-to-carry, and wants so badly to protect the revenue stream from permit fees, that he openly opposes the Second ...

What You Need to Know about ATF’s New eForms System

News  

Monday, January 10, 2022

What You Need to Know about ATF’s New eForms System

On December 23, ATF launched a new system for applicants to complete various forms that ATF is responsible for administrating. For most gun owners, this change will primarily impact how applications for firearms regulated under ...

Indiana: House Passes Lawful Carry, Sends To Senate

Wednesday, January 12, 2022

Indiana: House Passes Lawful Carry, Sends To Senate

Yesterday, the House voted 64-29 to pass House Bill 1077, the lawful carry bill. It will now go to the Senate for further consideration.

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

Gun Laws  

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

CAUTION: Federal and state firearms laws are subject to frequent change. This summary is not to be considered as legal advice or a restatement of law.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.