In response to a recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling, several local Pennsylvania politicians announced their intent to enact or continue to enforce local gun control laws. These politicians are either seriously misinformed about the effect of the court’s ruling or they intend to knowingly violate Pennsylvania law because they think there will be little, if any, recourse to their actions.
The court’s ruling last week in Leach v. Commonwealth effectively voided Pennsylvania Act 192 (2014). Act 192 provided gun owners who challenge local ordinances with the opportunity to recover their costs, if their challenge is successful, and made it easier for organizations, like NRA, to sue in order to block enforcement of local gun control ordinances. The Leach decision simply held that Act 192 was not passed with proper procedure, so its provisions are not enforceable. The decision does not affect the legality of Pennsylvania’s long-standing firearms preemption law.
Pennsylvania’s firearm preemption law was first passed in 1974. While it has been amended several times, its basic provision remains unchanged. Under the law, “[n]o county, municipality or township may in any manner regulate the lawful ownership, possession, transfer or transportation of firearms when carried or transported for purposes not prohibited by the laws of this Commonwealth.” As with the preemption laws in the vast majority of other states, this law has been interpreted to generally prohibit local governments from enforcing any firearm ordinances that are more restrictive than the laws of the state, or in this case, commonwealth.
Despite the fact that Pennsylvania’s preemption law remains in full force, local officials, emboldened by the court’s decision, seem intent on violating Pennsylvania law by passing new local gun controls. In a press release on the Supreme Court’s decision, Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney said “[t]his is a great victory for . . . the ability of local governments to adopt common sense gun regulations without fear of financially crippling litigation.” Allentown Mayor Ed Pawlowski went even further when he told a local news outlet of his plans to reintroduce an ordinance banning firearms in public buildings or parks. Allentown already had such a ban, but repealed it rather than defend the illegal ban in a lawsuit brought under the provisions of Act 192.
The boldness of these local officials in describing their intent to violate the law and their constituents’ civil rights is disturbing, but it also underscores the importance of firearm preemption laws and especially Act 192’s provisions that provide clear remedies for gun owners who sue to overturn illegal local gun control ordinances. An NRA-supported bill to reenact Act 192’s provisions has already been introduced in response to the court’s ruling.
Pennsylvania Politicians Announce Their Intent to Violate the Commonwealth’s Preemption Statute

Friday, July 1, 2016

Tuesday, September 26, 2023
On Tuesday, September 26th, California Governor Gavin Newsom hosted a signing ceremony in Sacramento where he signed multiple anti-gun bills into law, most notably: an 11% excise tax on all firearms and ammunition; vastly expanded concealed carry ...
Monday, September 25, 2023
The F-35 stealth jet isn’t the only example of expensive technology that crashed recently. The implementation of New York’s ammunition background check law – the rollout of which was, to be generous, extremely low visibility – was ...
Monday, September 25, 2023
Professional gun control advocates have always had a seat at the table in the Biden White House. Now, however, they will not only sit at the table but determine its menu, set it, and compile ...
Monday, July 17, 2023
Late last month, Massachusetts politicians put forth HD 4420, “an act modernizing firearm laws.” This massive piece of legislation re-writes gun laws in the Commonwealth and imposes unprecedented gun-control.
Friday, September 22, 2023
Gun Owners’ Action League (GOAL) will be holding a rally against HD 4420 “an act modernizing firearm laws,” on Wednesday, September 27th. NRA members and Second Amendment right supporters are encouraged to join the rally ...
More Like This From Around The NRA
