Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Buffaloed in New York: A Right Treated as a Privilege Makes an Easy Target for Revocation

Sunday, February 1, 2015

Buffaloed in New York: A Right Treated as a Privilege Makes an Easy Target for Revocation

During a press conference in November, Police Commissioner Daniel Derrenda of Buffalo, N.Y., announced that his department had “started a program where … we’re cross-referencing all the pistol permit holders with the death records … and … sending people out to collect the guns whenever possible.” He seemed haunted by the idea of handguns unattached to living licensees and spoke of them almost as if they were unsupervised, easily corruptible orphans: “At times, they lay out there, and the family is not aware of them … and they end up … just out on the street.”

The plan rightly enraged many as being overbearing. Fortunately, in the weeks since the announcement was made, we haven’t heard of any grieving survivors whose doors have been kicked down by police looking for their departed loved ones’ handguns.

Whatever the Buffalo PD may have in mind with this particular operation, it illustrates what can happen when the most basic and well-established of Second Amendment-protected rights—having a handgun in the home for self-protection—is subject to licensing and registration. While questions remain about if and how the plan will proceed, Commissioner Derrenda’s comments illustrate some of the assumptions that underlie the licensing and registration of firearms. All of them are incompatible with the idea of the Second Amendment as protecting a fundamental individual right that, as theHeller court wrote, “necessarily takes certain policy choices off the table.”

Before Heller, New York courts justified the state’s strict gun control laws by denying that the Second Amendment protected any sort of individual right. For example, a 2004 opinion by a three-judge panel of the Second Circuit that included Sonia Sotomayor—later nominated by President Obama to the U.S. Supreme Court—dismissed the appellant’s Second Amendment claim in a footnote. According to the appellant, merely being seen with a handgun could not be considered automatic evidence of criminality, and New York law to the contrary violated the Second Amendment. The court cited earlier Second Circuit precedent that stated, “The right to possess a gun is clearly not a fundamental right.” Of course, that precedent has been since been overruled by Heller and McDonald. Yet much of New York’s gun control regime has not only survived those decisions; rather, it has become even stricter in recent years.

Legal possession of a handgun in New York, even in one’s own home, requires a license. An applicant must demonstrate “good moral character” to the issuing official. Assuming that condition is met, the license can still be denied for “good cause,” whatever that might mean to the person who issues the license. New York courts have repeatedly ruled that these provisions give licensing officers discretion to expand upon the statutorily enumerated disqualifiers, even after Heller and McDonald.

Incredibly, a 2011 case from the Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court, decided nearly a year after the U.S. Supreme Court in McDonald ruled that possession of a handgun is a fundamental right, stated, “Possession of a handgun license is a privilege, not a right. …” As such, in New York, “it is subject to the broad discretion of the Police Commissioner.” Thus, for example, while certain misdemeanor convictions are automatic disqualifiers, a person can also be denied merely for having been accused of a crime, even if the complaint was ultimately dismissed or resolved in that person’s favor. So much for being innocent until proven guilty.

The U.S. Supreme Court’s clear decision that possessing a handgun is a fundamental right the state must respect, rather than merely a reward for what a local bureaucrat considers good behavior, is being massively resisted by the state of New York. It completely defies Heller’s pronouncement that the “very enumeration of the right takes out of the hands of government … the power to decide on a case-by-case basis whether the right is really worth insisting upon.”

No wonder, then, that Commissioner Derrenda presumes that any possession of a handgun that has not first received some official blessing is a problem to be solved, not the innocent exercise of an inalienable right. Those who insist that the exercise of rights can proceed only by permission—like the advocates of universal background checks—do so on the same basic assumptions. Where such measures are the law of the land, “collection” activities like the one announced in Buffalo should come as no surprise.

IN THIS ARTICLE
Chris W. Cox
Chris W. Cox

BY Chris W. Cox

NRA-ILA Executive Director

Follow This Contributor

Chris W. Cox has served as the executive director of the Institute for Legislative Action, the political and lobbying arm of NRA, since 2002. As NRA’s principal political strategist, Cox oversees eight NRA-ILA divisions: Federal Affairs; State & Local Affairs; Public Affairs; Grassroots; Finance; Research & Information; Conservation, Wildlife & Natural Resources; and Office of Legislative Counsel. Cox also serves as chairman of NRA’s Political Victory Fund (NRA-PVF), the Association’s political action committee; president of the NRA Freedom Action Foundation (NRA-FAF), which focuses on non-partisan voter registration and citizen education; and chairman of NRA Country, an effort to bring country music artists together with NRA members in support of our Second Amendment freedoms and hunting heritage.

TRENDING NOW
Illinois: Committee Passes Bill to Allow Local Infringement of Second Amendment

Wednesday, April 18, 2018

Illinois: Committee Passes Bill to Allow Local Infringement of Second Amendment

The Illinois state Senate could vote on legislation to allow localities to infringe upon Second Amendment rights as early as today.  Senate Bill 2314 was moved to third reading after it had passed the Senate ...

Unfriendly Skies: Delta CEO Claims Bashing NRA Members is Good Business

News  

Friday, April 13, 2018

Unfriendly Skies: Delta CEO Claims Bashing NRA Members is Good Business

In the wake of the Parkland, Florida, murders, there has been an unusual amount of anti-gun and anti-NRA commentary by private corporations with plenty of problems of their own.   In February, Delta announced it was ending a ...

Pennsylvania: Semi-Auto Ban Legislation to be Introduced

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Pennsylvania: Semi-Auto Ban Legislation to be Introduced

This week, Senator Wayne Fontana (D-Allegheny) started circulating a co-sponsorship memorandum soliciting members of the Pennsylvania state Senate to support a proposal to ban commonly owned semi-automatic firearms and standard capacity magazines in Pennsylvania.  Please ...

UK Officials Continue to Push Knife/Gun/Cleaning Products Control

News  

Friday, April 13, 2018

UK Officials Continue to Push Knife/Gun/Cleaning Products Control

The UK’s descent into absurdity continued this week as officials announced new efforts to crack down on knives and other potentially dangerous objects. The renewed interest in banning sharp objects stems from a recent spate of killings in London. ...

Illinois: Committees to Hear Gun Control

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

Illinois: Committees to Hear Gun Control

Today, the Illinois state House Judiciary-Criminal Committee will be considering a floor amendment that was added to House Bill 1470 to ration the exercise of Second Amendment rights. In addition, the state Senate Judiciary Committee will consider bills that would ...

New Jersey: Senate Committee Approves Gun Control Bills

Wednesday, April 18, 2018

New Jersey: Senate Committee Approves Gun Control Bills

On Monday, the Senate Law & Public Safety Committee approved several gun control bills during a hearing that stretched over five hours. 

Washington: Seattle to Consider Legislation to Make Firearms Unavailable for Self-Defense

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

Washington: Seattle to Consider Legislation to Make Firearms Unavailable for Self-Defense

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan and Councilmember M. Lorena González have announced their intention to introduce legislation to impose a one-size-fits-all method of storing firearms as well as punishing victims of theft by requiring reporting of lost or ...

Bailed-out Banks Launch Coordinated Attack on Law-abiding Gun Owners

News  

Friday, April 13, 2018

Bailed-out Banks Launch Coordinated Attack on Law-abiding Gun Owners

There is growing evidence that some of America’s financial elite want to create a world in which America’s public policy decisions emanate from corporate boardrooms in Manhattan rather than from citizens and their elected officials.  ...

NRA backs Challenge to Vermont Magazine Ban

News  

Wednesday, April 18, 2018

NRA backs Challenge to Vermont Magazine Ban

The National Rifle Association Institute for Legislative Action (NRA-ILA) today announced support for a lawsuit brought by Vermont citizens, sporting-goods stores, and shooting clubs to challenge the state¹s recent ban on many of the most ...

Trial Judge Mocks the Late Justice Scalia While Upholding Expansive Gun Ban

Second Amendment  

News  

Friday, April 13, 2018

Trial Judge Mocks the Late Justice Scalia While Upholding Expansive Gun Ban

Gun owners have seen many outrageous instances of courts dismissing the importance, if not the very existence, of the individual right to keep and bear arms. But Judge William G. Young of the U.S. District ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -
NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.