Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Sparking Dialogue or Sparking Joy: Competing Views on Gun “Buyback” Initiatives

Sunday, August 18, 2019

Sparking Dialogue or Sparking Joy: Competing Views on Gun “Buyback” Initiatives

The Christian Science Monitor describes itself as “an independent international news organization” that wants to “help you to see news events as starting points for constructive conversations.” Its editorial board recently published an article, A seed for society’s safety: Gun buybacks, discussing why New Zealand’s “gun buyback” program could serve as a useful model on how the government can engage with gun owners in this country.

According to the piece, the “voluntary nature of gun buybacks – along with the incentive of being compensated – gives them a special place in the worldwide debate over gun regulations.”

In the case of the New Zealand program, it is neither a “buyback” nor voluntary. Apart from the quibble that the privately-owned guns have not been owned or sold by the government such that any later relinquishment is, in fact, a “buy back,” there’s nothing optional about the program, unless the decision between surrendering your property or facing hard jail time can be said to represent a real and honest choice.

Under New Zealand’s new firearm law, the Arms (Prohibited Firearms, Magazines, and Parts) Amendment Regulations 2019, the possession of “prohibited firearms, magazines and parts” is a crime, although the law includes an “amnesty period” which runs until December 20, 2019. Residents are forbidden to use these firearms during that period; the purpose of the amnesty is solely to give private owners and licensed dealers time in which to surrender their property to the police. The compensation for doing so is restricted by a “base price” set by the government, with an automatic discount built-in – a new firearm is only eligible for maximum compensation of 95% of the base price, and compensation for certain new magazines or parts is capped at 70% of the base price amount. Under the government’s price list, for example, compensation for a new suppressor cannot exceed $350, even though the assigned base value is $500. Moreover, no compensation is being offered for ammunition and other accessories (like optical scopes) that become useless without a firearm. 

Such “incentivizing” compensation cannot eclipse the fact that compliance with the New Zealand program rests on the threat of criminal prosecution. The New Zealand Police warn that “people should hand in their prohibited firearms, magazines and parts during the amnesty period.” If they do not, or “do not demonstrate any intent to do so, then Police will take action.” Criminal penalties for the new possession offenses begin at two years’ imprisonment for possessing a prohibited part or magazine, and increase exponentially.

There are other fundamental problems with gun “buybacks.” The CSM article admits that “criminals or potential mass shooters are very unlikely to turn in their guns,” and the “effectiveness of such buybacks” in reducing crime “is highly uncertain.”

Nonetheless, the CSM argues the value of these programs is that they “help stir the thinking of gun owners,” as the “popular buyback program” in New Zealand allegedly sparked a nationwide attitude shift. Such “programs help bring gun owners in contact with police and others in a community, fostering a dialogue about the ways to keep everyone safe,” because New Zealand’s gun owners, “when given an opportunity to think about safety, took their arms to the police rather than taking up arms.”

This completely misses the point. Law-abiding citizens are not the ones responsible for crimes and firearm violence, and fostering a “dialogue” that appears to pave the way for a “second tranche” of even more government restrictions on legitimate gun owners will not change this. A compulsory government program of firearm confiscation is only “popular” in the same way that paying income tax is “popular” – few (if any) would volunteer to opt in absent the element of criminal sanctions. And if government “buybacks” are really and truly about promoting community safety, it makes no sense to shrug off the critical detail that criminals and other evil-minded persons are “very unlikely” to be the ones giving up their guns.

Closer to home, a voluntary “buyback” program in Baltimore, Maryland provides insight into the actual transformative impact of these events, which appears to be less Kumbaya than KonMarie.

Last December, officials in Baltimore held a series of gun “buybacks” for city residents. Any resident who wanted to turn in their gun or magazine was free to do so, including any “legitimate gun owner” who no longer had “a need for that weapon.” Then-mayor Catherine E. Pugh candidly explained that the objective was to take in as many guns as possible, regardless of their potential for use in street crime. “Our point here is, there are guns on the streets of our city. We are signaling folks out there, we don’t care if it’s Grandpa’s gun or your gun, we want it.” The city paid up to $500 in cash for each firearm, irrespective of condition, and $25 for every “high capacity” (over ten round) magazine. All transactions were completely anonymous.

Savvy citizens could use the event to make a quick profit on magazines (retailing, in many cases, at significantly less than $25) or their inoperative wall-hangers. One happy participant brought in the barreled action of a bolt action shotgun; another advised she was turning in a handgun so she could upgrade to a better gun. One source described the overall haul as akin to “the bargain table (or maybe trash bin) at your local gun show.” And although the buyback was open to Baltimore residents only, the no-questions-asked process potentially meant that anyone within driving distance could cash in.

While those at the CSM are certainly free to believe that buybacks “help bring a community together to look at the foundations of peace,” an editorial in the Baltimore Sun more practically concluded that the event was a complete waste of government resources. Momentous language about the deliverance of peace aside, it observed that too often, “buybacks” do more towards decluttering basements than reducing the number of guns in the hands of criminals.          

IN THIS ARTICLE
gun "buyback"
TRENDING NOW
Amtrak to Amend Firearms Policy to Align with President Trump’s 2A Executive Order

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Amtrak to Amend Firearms Policy to Align with President Trump’s 2A Executive Order

Gun owners may soon have an easier time traveling by Amtrak, with President Donald Trump to thank. Reports indicate that the heavily federally subsidized train service will change its policy starting in January 2027 to ...

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Monday, November 9, 2026

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Prefiling of legislative bills for the 2027 Regular Session of the Texas State Legislature began today. On the first day alone, legislators filed roughly 35 firearm-related bills, with the vast majority aimed are infringing on ...

Judge Rules DOJ Lacks Authority to Pursue Second Amendment Violations

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Judge Rules DOJ Lacks Authority to Pursue Second Amendment Violations

Harmeet Dhillon, the now-former Assistant Attorney General of the U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (CRIT), has been appropriately hailed as “a jewel for justice” and “the face of the [Trump] administration’s commitment to ...

Democrats Promised Affordability Agenda, Immediately Pivot to Pursuing Gun Control

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Democrats Promised Affordability Agenda, Immediately Pivot to Pursuing Gun Control

The election is over. The time for lamenting the results has passed. This is especially the case in states where anti-gun Democrats have secured complete control of government as their gun control proposals are already ...

ATF Director Robert Cekada Unbowed After Midterms: “We’re Forging Ahead”

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

ATF Director Robert Cekada Unbowed After Midterms: “We’re Forging Ahead”

Recently, we reported on the departure of two key figures in the Trump administration’s pro-Second Amendment agenda.

Minnesota: Gun Control Wish List Policies Moved to New Bill

Friday, May 1, 2026

Minnesota: Gun Control Wish List Policies Moved to New Bill

It would seem that gun control radicals in the Minnesota legislature cannot decide on what bill to put their gun control package in, and have again moved them to another bill. 

Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

Friday, November 13, 2026

Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

The election is over, but national gun control groups are already setting their sights on Nevadan's Second Amendment rights.   

Jive Turkeys: Everytown Gears Up to Spoil Thanksgiving with Gobbledygook

News  

Monday, November 17, 2025

Jive Turkeys: Everytown Gears Up to Spoil Thanksgiving with Gobbledygook

Thanksgiving in America isn’t just about food, family and football. According to a survey published by casino.ca (with its Great Thanksgiving Family Feud Map), the holiday typically “comes with a slice of family chaos and a touch of ...

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

Friday, November 13, 2026

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

House Bill 6477, introduced this week by Rep. Sharon MacDonell (D-Troy) and referred to the House Committee on Government Operations, amends Michigan’s License to Purchase (LTP) law (MCL 28.422). It adds a new training requirement before ...

Ohio: Strengthened Preemption Bill with New Carry Provisions Advances

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Ohio: Strengthened Preemption Bill with New Carry Provisions Advances

The House Judiciary Committee has advanced Senate Bill 278, legislation to strengthen Ohio’s existing firearm preemption law.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.