Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

Expanding NYPD Gun License Corruption Scandal Shows Need for Reform

Friday, April 28, 2017

Expanding NYPD Gun License Corruption Scandal Shows Need for Reform

Further scandal hit the New York City Police Department’s License Division this week as federal prosecutors charged four individuals in two separate bribery conspiracies following a wide-ranging corruption investigation concerning the city’s issuance of handgun licenses. The latest round of charges comes a year after news broke of severe corruption within the License Division when federal prosecutors charged prominent Brooklyn businessman Alex “Shaya” Lichtenstein for bribing division officials to shepherd certain handgun license applications through the licensing process. The latest charges suggests that the corruption went to the highest levels of the License Division, and that handgun licenses were essentially up for sale.

New York City has an incredibly onerous handgun licensing scheme. Under this may-issue regime, law enforcement is granted wide discretion to grant or deny a license. Applicants can be denied for something as simple as “a poor driving history,” or as vague as any “other good cause.” The process is also expensive. Applicants must pay a $340.00 application fee and an $89.75 fingerprinting fee.

New York’s handgun licensing process is so convoluted and difficult that it has created an industry of “gun license expeditors.” These individuals offer to navigate New York’s handgun licensing procedure on an applicant’s behalf for a sizeable fee. According to the recent complaints, several such “expeditors” successfully bribed License Division officials to acquire, expedite, renew, or retain handgun licenses for their clients.

According to the complaint in one of the bribery conspiracies, former NYPD Lieutenant Paul Dean, and fellow former officer Robert Espinel engaged in wide-ranging corruption involving the issuance of handgun licenses. Federal officials described Dean as “one of the highest-ranking members of the License Division,” who had “ultimate authority to approve or reject licenses.”

The complaint contends that over the course of several years Dean and Espinel “sought and/or obtained cash, paid vacations, personal jewelry, catered parties, guns, gun paraphernalia and other benefits from multiple expediters.” Such bribes allegedly also included alcohol, exotic dancers, and prostitutes.

The complaint goes on to allege that “not satisfied with the bribes provided to them by expediters in light of the amounts the expediters were charging their clients, [Dean and Espinel] decided to retire and go into the expediting business themselves,” with the intention of bribing their former colleagues. Further, the prosecutors allege that Dean and Espinel attempted to “corner the expediting market” by threatening to shut out other expeditors unless they worked through them.

The complaint alleges that individuals who would have almost certainly been denied a handgun license were approved for licenses in the scope of this bribery scheme. A federal press release noted that the License Division “approved licenses for individuals with substantial criminal histories, including arrests and convictions for crimes involving weapons or violence, and for individuals with histories of domestic violence.”

In one such case, an expeditor brought the application of a client with “prior convictions for criminal possession of a weapon and assault with intent to cause injury.” A colleague of Dean’s warned the expeditor that approving this individual’s application would be difficult and that the applicant would could have trouble even passing a dealer background check to obtain a firearm. According to the complaint, Dean suggested that if the applicant knew a person without a criminal record they could buy a firearm for the applicant. Dean and his colleague later approved the applicant’s handgun license.

In a separate case, former Assistant District Attorney for Kings County and gun license expeditor John Chambers was charged with bribing a License Division official. According to the complaint, Chambers provided a License Division official with “free tickets to sporting and entertainment events…, free dinners and lunches..., sports memorabilia, and a Paul Picot wristwatch.”

The complaint alleges that in exchange for these items, the License Division official would significantly reduce the time to complete license renewal applications. Further, the official allegedly assisted in cases involving an “incident investigation,” where the License Division is tasked with determining whether an individual’s license should be suspended or revoked. The complaint contends that the official would expedite the resolution of an incident investigation or lessen the length of a license suspension period, and that he assisted Chambers in “50 to 100” such instances.

This summary has only touched on the alleged corruption in the NYPD License Division and those interested in learning more about this case are encouraged to visit the website for the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York and read the complaints.

Lichtenstein reportedly charged those seeking a permit up to $18,000 for his services. Chambers allegedly charged clients $3,000 to $5,000 for license renewals. Dean and Espinel allegedly retired to pursue this lucrative business. The alleged actions of these individuals, and the others alleged to have been involved in this bribery scandal, are wrong, but it is New York City’s misguided firearms licensing regime that has allowed this culture of graft to thrive.

Individuals should not have to pay to exercise their Second Amendment rights, however, many are willing to do so. While some of the license applicants discussed in the complaints were potentially prohibited from possessing firearms under federal law, there is no indication that many were not simply law-abiding individuals attempting to gain access to their constitutional rights and ignorant of the illegal means these expediters employed.

At a press conference announcing the arrests, Acting Manhattan U.S. Attorney Joon H. Kim accused those charged with perverting “the critically important police function of issuing and controlling gun licenses.” Of course, if such licensing procedures are in place they should be administered in a trustworthy manner. However, may-issue schemes of this type are not a critical government function, as proven by the 42 shall-issue states that span every portion of this country and the superior conduct of Right-to-Carry permit holders as a class of citizens.

Police corruption in the issuance of gun licenses is detestable, but merely a symptom of the underlying problem. In fact, there is evidence that New York City’s handgun licensing law, the Sullivan Act, was passed to facilitate the sort of unscrupulous dealing these police are alleged to have committed. In order prevent this type of conduct in the future, New York City should reform its outmoded licensing procedure with one that better respects the rights of city residents.

TRENDING NOW
“Fact Checker:” Joe Biden’s “Gun Ban” Not a Gun Ban Because Some Guns Wouldn’t Be Banned

News  

Monday, July 15, 2019

“Fact Checker:” Joe Biden’s “Gun Ban” Not a Gun Ban Because Some Guns Wouldn’t Be Banned

Facebook has teamed up with what it calls “third-party fact-checkers” to punish users of its platform that post information embarrassing or inconvenient to this outlook. Yet like most sources of what passes as “news” or ...

Hollywood Fantasy v. Reality on Firearm Suppressors

News  

Monday, July 15, 2019

Hollywood Fantasy v. Reality on Firearm Suppressors

It’s no secret that Hollywood has a very loose relationship with reality.  The movie industry, after all, is based on fantasy and escapism, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing.  If someone wants to forget ...

California: City of San Diego Considers Gun Control Ordinance

Friday, July 12, 2019

California: City of San Diego Considers Gun Control Ordinance

San Diego City Attorney, Mara Elliott has asked the City Council to consider a draft ordinance that would require mandatory locked storage of firearms in the home and would propose a conflicting law regarding the reporting of ...

California: Injunction Request to be Filed in Lawsuit Challenging California Ammo Law

Wednesday, July 3, 2019

California: Injunction Request to be Filed in Lawsuit Challenging California Ammo Law

CRPA, with the support of NRA, challenged the ammunition background check law in court months ago with the filing of the Rhode v. Becerra case. The lead plaintiff in the case is Olympic gold medalist shooter ...

Hawaii: Governor Ige Signs Anti-Gun Legislation

Wednesday, July 10, 2019

Hawaii: Governor Ige Signs Anti-Gun Legislation

On July 9th, Governor David Ige signed the final remaining anti-gun bill awaiting his consideration, Senate Bill 600. This comes on the heels of him signing Senate Bill 1466 on June 27th. 

Presidential Pretender Who Campaigned on Gun Control First to Call It Quits

News  

Monday, July 15, 2019

Presidential Pretender Who Campaigned on Gun Control First to Call It Quits

On Monday, Eric Swalwell became the first of the many pretenders for the Democrat presidential nomination to bow (or perhaps slink) out of the race. The U.S. Congressman from California’s 15th District had tried to distinguish himself from ...

Vox Wants to Take Your Guns

News  

Monday, July 8, 2019

Vox Wants to Take Your Guns

A conspiracy relies on secrecy. Some are, perhaps, never uncovered. Others are exposed by the conspirators themselves, who cannot help but share the details whether from arrogance or anxiousness. For years, law-abiding gun owners and ...

California: Legislature Breaks for Summer Recess

Sunday, July 14, 2019

California: Legislature Breaks for Summer Recess

The California Legislature has recessed for the summer and will return August 12 from the break. Last week, the following actions were taken by the Senate Public Safety Committee, Senate Natural Resources, and both the Senate ...

Recent Poll Shows Gun Control Not as Popular as Some Would Like to Believe

News  

Monday, July 8, 2019

Recent Poll Shows Gun Control Not as Popular as Some Would Like to Believe

A recent Morning Consult/POLITICO poll, conducted immediately prior to the recent  Democratic debates and gathering responses from 1,991 registered voters, asked about views toward the candidates, issues of potential importance in the election, voting intention, and ...

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

Gun Laws  

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

CAUTION: Federal and state firearms laws are subject to frequent change. This summary is not to be considered as legal advice or a restatement of law.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.