Municipal Firearms Litigation “Scorecard”

Complete Dismissals

Appeals Re: State Preemption Statutes

Fully & Finally Adjudicated Cases

Bridgeport        -  Affirmed CT Supreme Court

Miami               -  Affirmed FL Appellate Court,

                            petition denied by FL S. Ct.

New Orleans      - Affirmed LA S. Ct., cert.

                           denied by U.S. S. Ct.

Camden County - Affirmed U.S. 3^rd Cir.

                            Court of Appeals

Philadelphia       - Affirmed U.S. 3^rd Cir. Court

                            of Appeals

Atlanta               - Case dismissed by GA Court of

                            Appeals

Dismissals On Appeal

Chicago

Cincinnati – Affirmed by Court of Appeals

Gary

New York State

Voluntary Dismissals

Boston – with prejudice

Detroit/Wayne County

Cases Terminated Based on State Preemption

New Orleans (retroactive)

Philadelphia

Atlanta (retroactive)

Partial Dismissals On Interlocutory Appeal

Detroit/Wayne County

Newark

Partial Dismissal – Pending Cases

Dismissal Denied – Pending Cases

Newark                 - Motion for interlocutory

                               appeal granted

Wilmington           - Discovery limited to city’s

                               damages; summary judgment

                               to be filed

Detroit/Wayne Co. - Interlocutory appeal pending

California               - Restitution & disgorgement

                                claims dismissed

Cleveland – Stayed pending Cincinnati appeal

Pending Motions to Dismiss

No Motion to Dismiss Filed

Camden City

St. Louis

Washington, DC

New York City – Case stayed pending appeal of

                         NY State case

Jersey City      – Complaint filed March 28, 2002