Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Grotesque attack proves New York’s subways are NOT “sensitive places”

Monday, March 7, 2022

Grotesque attack proves New York’s subways are NOT “sensitive places”

Since the District of Columbia v. Heller decision in 2008, gun control advocates have parsed every word of Justice Antonin Scalias opinion for ways in which to continue their campaign against the Second Amendment. Relying on creative interpretations of dicta, these activists try to twist the landmark gun rights ruling into an endorsement of their anti-gun policies.

An example of these efforts is on display in the NRA-supported case New York Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. The case concerns the validity New Yorks discretionary carry licensing regime, where law enforcement is tasked with determining if an applicant has proper causeto carry a firearm for self-defense.

In the Heller decision, Scalia stated, nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt onlaws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings…” Gun control advocates have seized on the sensitive placeslanguage in an attempt to lend legitimacy to blanket restrictions on the Right-to-Carry for self-defense.

In their brief defending the may-issue licensing regime, New York argued,

New York’s law is a historically grounded approach to protecting sensitive places of the type that every State, the federal government, and this Court have recognized the need to safeguard.

The reply brief from NYSRPA correctly noted,

[the plaintiffs] do not challenge any of New York’s many separate laws prohibiting handguns in specific, sensitive places. They contest New York’s effort to treat virtually the entire Empire State as a sensitive place and to prohibit petitioners from carrying their handguns for self-defense virtually anywhere,

This battle surrounding sensitive placesloomed large in the briefs. Moreover, a particular supposed sensitive placewas repeatedly invoked by the state New York Citys subways.

The states brief cited subways” as sensitive places.” Moreover, during the November 3, oral arguments, New York Solicitor General Barbara Underwood endorsed the notion that subways are sensitive places.”

In posing a question to Underwood, Justice Samuel Alito said,

None of these people has a criminal record. They're all law-abiding citizens. They get off work around midnight, maybe even after midnight. They have to commute home by subway, maybe by bus. When they arrive at the subway station or the bus stop, they have to walk some distance through a high-crime area, and they apply for a license, and they say: Look, nobody has told -- has said I am going to mug you next Thursday. However, there have been a lot of muggings in this area, and I am scared to death.

They do not get licenses, is that right?

Defending New York law while responding to Alito, Underwood, in part, stated,

I think the extra problem in Manhattan is that you – your hypothetical quite appropriately entailed the subways, entailed public transit, and there are lots of people on the subways even at midnight, as I can say from personal experience, and the particular specter of a lot of armed people in an enclosed space --

and,

Well, I think the subways, when there are problems on the subways, are protected by the -- the -- the transit police, is what happens, because the idea of proliferating arms on the subway is precisely, I think, what terrifies a great many people.

The issue of New Yorks subways loomed so large, that Justice Elena Kagan appeared to entertain the notion that they are sensitive places.”

After being questioned by Chief Justice John Roberts as to what might constitute a sensitive place,NYSRPA counsel Paul Clement responded with how a location might be analyzed. Clement offered, in part,

One is, you know, restriction of access to the place is something that I think would be consistent with the way government buildings have worked and schools have worked. Not any member of the general public can come in there. They restrict access. With -- with or without a gun, if you're an adult that has no business to be in a school, you're excluded. So I think that's a factor that would support treating that as a sensitive place.

Kagan pressed the topic, by asking,

what the Chief Justice is trying to do is figure out how those cash out in the real world. So I'll give you a few more. New York City subways.

The notion that New York Citys subway system is a sensitive place,under any conceivable definition of the term, should be absurd to any person who has had the displeasure of using it. The utterly filthy structure frequently plays host to the most outrageous scenes of crime and human degradation.

However, a recent incident illustrated just how non-sensitive the New York City subway system is in fact and made clear that the state of New York doesnt consider it a sensitive placein practice.

According to police, on February 21 a 43-year-old woman was on a bench in a subway station in the Bronx when a man approached her. The man was carrying a plastic bag filled with human excrement, which he pushed into the womans face. An account from the New York Post stated that the man smashed the vile contents of the bag in her face, and then smeared it on the back of her head.The entire attack was captured on video.

Police arrested the alleged attacker on February 28 and he was arraigned on March 1. While he was detained, the suspect reportedly joked about his alleged crime. The New York Post reported that he told the police S–t happens. Haha. This is a stty situation. Haha.The Post also noted that during the arraignment the suspect snapped F---k you, b---hto the judge and referred to the victim as a b---h.

Despite the atrocious nature of his alleged crime, and outrageous courtroom conduct, the suspect was released without bail.

Two days after being released, the suspect was rearrested on hate crime charges stemming from antisemitic assault last September. According to the Posts summary of the charges, the suspect allegedly spat on a Jewish man and chased him down a Brooklyn street, screaming, Come here, you f—king Jew, I am going to kill you.’” The suspect was again released without bail.

A further investigation of the suspects criminal history showed that he had 44 prior arrests. Moreover, WABC reported,

Authorities say [the suspect] has a history of transit related attacks. On January 7, he allegedly punched a 30-year-man on the subway platform at the 125th Street station at Lenox Avenue in Harlem.

And on February 5, he allegedly punched a 53-year-old man at the Port Authority Bus Terminal.

According to the state of New York, the New York City subway system is too sensitive” a place for law-abiding citizens to carry a firearm for self-defense. However, the subway is not so sensitive as to prompt the state to incapacitate an individual that is credibly accused of repeated heinous acts of violence in and around the transit system.

This position is ludicrous and untenable. Moreover, it demonstrates that the state is more concerned with restricting the rights of the law-abiding than protecting the public from those who commit criminal violence.

TRENDING NOW
Florida: House Passes Constitutional Carry

Friday, March 24, 2023

Florida: House Passes Constitutional Carry

Today, the House voted 76-32 to pass House Bill 543, the constitutional carry bill.

Seattle’s Gun Tax: A Textbook Case on the Law of Inverse Consequences

News  

Monday, March 27, 2023

Seattle’s Gun Tax: A Textbook Case on the Law of Inverse Consequences

The law of inverse or unintended consequences refers to outcomes that are the reverse of the planned or expected results. As described in another context, “the law of unintended consequences could create a perverse effect contrary to ...

Updates to ATF Final Rule on Stabilizing Braces

News  

Monday, January 30, 2023

Updates to ATF Final Rule on Stabilizing Braces

On Monday, January 30, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives’ (ATF) published the final Factoring Criteria for Firearms with Attached “Stabilizing Braces” rule for public inspection in the federal register.

Florida: Senate Passes Constitutional Carry

Thursday, March 30, 2023

Florida: Senate Passes Constitutional Carry

Today, the Senate voted 27-13 to pass House Bill 543, the constitutional carry bill received from the House last week.

North Carolina: VETO OVERRIDDEN

Wednesday, March 29, 2023

North Carolina: VETO OVERRIDDEN

Today, March 29, the House voted 71-46 to override Governor Cooper’s veto of Senate Bill 41, a bill that recognizes law-abiding citizens’ right to self-defense while attending a church with a school attached and also repeals the ...

Florida: Senate’s Constitutional Carry Passes Committee

Thursday, March 9, 2023

Florida: Senate’s Constitutional Carry Passes Committee

Today, the Senate Fiscal Policy Committee voted 11-6 to approve Senate Bill 150, constitutional carry, with an amendment aligning the language with the House’s version. It will now go to the full Senate for further consideration.

Biden’s Executive Order Targeting Gun Ownership

News  

Wednesday, March 15, 2023

Biden’s Executive Order Targeting Gun Ownership

On Tuesday, Joe Biden issued an executive order on gun control that could accurately be described as a mile wide and an inch deep.

Nebraska: Constitutional Carry PASSED Second Vote, ONE MORE VOTE TO GO

Tuesday, March 28, 2023

Nebraska: Constitutional Carry PASSED Second Vote, ONE MORE VOTE TO GO

Today the Nebraska Legislature voted 31-10 to pass Legislative Bill 77, “LB 77” by Senator Tom Brewer, the constitutional carry bill on Select File.  This bill recognizes the fundamental right of law-abiding adults to carry firearms for ...

Colorado: Assault Weapon Ban Committee Hearing Scheduled!

Monday, March 27, 2023

Colorado: Assault Weapon Ban Committee Hearing Scheduled!

On March 29, the House Judiciary Committee is scheduled to vote on House Bill 23-1230 (“HB 23-1230”), which bans the manufacturing, importing, purchasing, selling, offering to sell, or transferring ownership of what the drafters have defined as ...

Florida: 2023 Session Convened, Senate Committee Hearing Constitutional Carry

Wednesday, March 8, 2023

Florida: 2023 Session Convened, Senate Committee Hearing Constitutional Carry

Yesterday, March 7th, the Florida Legislature began the 2023 legislative session. Tomorrow, at 9:00AM, the Senate Fiscal Policy Committee will hear Senate Bill 150, the Senate’s constitutional carry bill.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.