Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Canada’s Senate Holds Hearings on “Rube Goldberg” Gun Control Law, Bill C-71

Friday, March 15, 2019

Canada’s Senate Holds Hearings on “Rube Goldberg” Gun Control Law, Bill C-71

Last month, the Senate Standing Committee on National Security and Defence (SECD) concluded two days of hearings on Bill C-71, the Liberal government’s gun control bill. (An additional hearing date has been set for March 18, 2019.) The committee has so far heard from approximately 40 witnesses, including gun rights advocates, gun control groups, the Assembly of First Nations of Quebec and Labrador, researchers and academics, sport shooting associations, industry groups, small business owners, Statistics Canada, community activists, and others.

These hearings showcased the wide range of stakeholders in the current debate on the policy and effectiveness of Bill C-71. They also revealed that despite the differences between Canada and the United States, certain legislators in both countries share an unshakeable belief that the best way to respond to the criminal misuse of firearms is to ramp up restrictions on law-abiding gun owners.

One of the common themes in both the testimony and the committee member questions was the lack of objective, empirical evidence to support the bill measures, and the bill’s failure to address the real issues of the illegal firearm trade and sources of illegal guns, and the rise in street gang crime.

Dr. Caillin Langmann, the author of a 2012 study on firearm laws and homicide in Canada, testified he found no association between firearm homicides and laws imposing background checks, authorizations to transport, classification of firearms, or gun registries. Regarding suicide specifically, suicide by firearms in Canada “has been on a steady decline,” as compared to suicide by other methods (“on a slow, steady increase”). Another researcher, Dr. Gary Mauser, described Bill C-71 as “a Rube Goldberg contraption” (unlike those ridiculously overcomplicated mechanisms, though, the bill “misses the target completely”). “No evidence has been produced that [possession and acquisition license] holders are a major source of crime guns. No evidence has been produced that there are significant abuses of the authorizations to transport restricted firearms.” Even the number of license holders accused of homicide was so small that moose in Canada killed more people each year than registered and licensed firearms owners.

Among the insightful presentations in opposition to the bill were those of Chief Ghislain Picard, on behalf of the Assembly of First Nations of Quebec and Labrador, who appeared with Stuart Wuttke, legal counsel for the Assembly of First Nations. He began by indicating that members of the First Nations “have been using firearms for a long time … for their cultural and traditional activities” and “have the right to pass on their culture to future generations without outside interference.” Bill C-71 not only raised “major constitutional concerns” but potentially had serious repercussions on First Nations’ rights and cultural heritage. Legislators should do more to directly address gang violence rather than add “unnecessary restrictions on the rights of licensed gun owners, “We stand with the many other Canadians who are not willing to forfeit their fundamental rights and freedoms, who are asking that this government engage in more careful crafting of this important piece of legislation.”

One concern consistently identified throughout the hearing was the ability of the existing bureaucracy to adequately address the shift to what would be required under the bill, including a change from a “five year” background check to the bill’s proposed “lifetime” background check. A senator observed that the RCMP was already experiencing “significant problems” in conducting mental health and domestic violence checks in at least one province, with a backlog of some 2,000 cases as of 2017. Testimony about another province’s office indicated it was “behind in their transfer requests for businesses by 4,500” in 2018. In theory, the bill would provide more rigorous screening, but – as pointed out by those testifying for the firearm industry and businesses – the bill lacked any funding for the increased responsibilities that it imposed. Going forward, there was nothing to ensure that the entities charged with implementation would be adequately funded, adequately trained, and “adequately resourced.”   

The Committee members spent a significant amount of time discussing the bill with these witnesses, representatives of the Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association (CSAAA). The CSAAA panel identified several serious shortcomings with C-71 (“ill-conceived, ideologically driven and minus any input or consideration on the significant impacts it will have on the 4,500 licensed firearm businesses in Canada or the 25,000 employees who work in these community businesses”). For example, the bill establishes the RCMP as the “product regulatory body” for the firearms industry, but without any oversight from elected officials or structured guidelines, an appeal process, or a way for the industry to participate. Pointing to the RCMP’s previous unilateral changes in classifications of firearms, a business owner described how one reclassification to “prohibited” status caused a $38,000 devaluation in inventory for his business due to 500 firearms that could no longer be sold or transferred. Another concern was the bill’s delegation of new record-keeping requirements on the gun industry and business owners so the government could “avoid being pegged as the creator of a new long-gun registry,” without regard for the insurance, legal liability, and compliance impact on these businesses.

The evidence presented in the hearings did not mention any official estimated costs for the implementation and enforcement of Bill C-71. Canadians burned by the cost of the spectacularly expensive and now defunct federal long-gun registry might be interested in the testimony of Dennis Young, a retired RCMP officer. Despite the RCMP having ceased reporting the spending and employment numbers for the Canadian Firearms Program to Parliament, Mr. Young has been able to estimate spending using government sources. According to him, total spending on the firearms program for the years 1995 to 2017 was between $1.79 billion and $1.6 billion. For the years 2016 and 2017, the Canadian Firearms Program cost taxpayers $53.7 million and employed an equivalent of 451 full-time employees. These costs will only increase should the bill be passed.       

Senator Marilou McPhedran (Manitoba) contributed some of the more peculiar moments of the hearings when she pressed certain witnesses as to whether they were “funded in any way or affiliated in any way with the National Rifle Association of the United States,” being unwilling to believe, apparently, that ordinary Canadians could harbor genuine and honestly-held concerns about the effectiveness, utility and costs of the bill. None of the witnesses (unsurprisingly) had any such funding or ties to disclose. 

This summary can only touch upon some of the evidence; transcripts of the proceedings can be reviewed here (February 18) and here (February 25).   

While these hearings are sure to interest Americans who follow developments in our neighbor to the north, they also provide a forceful reminder of the value of the Second Amendment. A witness for a gun control organization who testified in support of the bill expressed her dismay over the proliferation of legal firearms in Canada, citing the need to enact additional bans and restrictions to reverse that trend. According to her, there was no downside to imposing greater gun control laws because “there are no gun owner rights in this county.” 

 

 

TRENDING NOW
Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Monday, November 9, 2026

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Prefiling of legislative bills for the 2027 Regular Session of the Texas State Legislature began today. On the first day alone, legislators filed roughly 35 firearm-related bills, with the vast majority aimed are infringing on ...

DOJ Files Amicus Brief Supporting NRA-Backed Challenge to IL’s Ban on “Assault Weapons” and “Large-Capacity Magazines”

Tuesday, June 17, 2025

DOJ Files Amicus Brief Supporting NRA-Backed Challenge to IL’s Ban on “Assault Weapons” and “Large-Capacity Magazines”

Last Friday, the U.S. Department of Justice filed an amicus brief in the Seventh Circuit supporting an NRA-backed challenge to Illinois’s prohibition on so-called “assault weapons” and “large-capacity magazines.”

Buckle Up, Friends: DOJ Opens New 2A Division, Promises “A Lot More Action” to Safeguard Rights

News  

Monday, December 15, 2025

Buckle Up, Friends: DOJ Opens New 2A Division, Promises “A Lot More Action” to Safeguard Rights

In a landmark accomplishment in furtherance of President Donald J. Trump’s Executive Order on the Second Amendment, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has announced the creation of a new section under its Civil Rights Division - ...

Trump Administration Loses Two of its Brightest Second Amendment Lights

News  

Monday, November 9, 2026

Trump Administration Loses Two of its Brightest Second Amendment Lights

Along with other difficult tidings, the last couple of weeks brought the unfortunate news that two key figures in the Trump administration’s Second Amendment Renaissance were leaving government service. 

Trump DOJ to Investigate Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department for Permit Delays

News  

Monday, March 31, 2025

Trump DOJ to Investigate Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department for Permit Delays

The United States Supreme Court, in its landmark Bruen decision recognizing a right to carry in public for self-defense, did not foreclose shall-issue licensing as being consistent with the Second Amendment.

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

Friday, November 13, 2026

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

House Bill 6477, introduced this week by Rep. Sharon MacDonell (D-Troy) and referred to the House Committee on Government Operations, amends Michigan’s License to Purchase (LTP) law (MCL 28.422). It adds a new training requirement before ...

Virginia Attorney General Jay Jones Reveals Ignorance on Basic Firearms Technology

News  

Monday, November 9, 2026

Virginia Attorney General Jay Jones Reveals Ignorance on Basic Firearms Technology

Back in 2019, David Harsanyi penned an article titled, If You’re Trying To Ban Guns, The Least You Can Do Is Learn The Basics, which focused on complaints of “gunsplaining” by gun control advocates objecting ...

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

News  

Friday, February 3, 2017

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

On Thursday, the U.S. House of Representatives issued a strong statement in support of the Second Amendment by passing H.J. Res. 40, which would repeal Barack Obama’s scandalous attempt to grab guns from thousands of vulnerable, ...

Arizona: Anti-Gun Lawmakers Waste No Time Taking Aim at Second Amendment Rights

Friday, November 6, 2026

Arizona: Anti-Gun Lawmakers Waste No Time Taking Aim at Second Amendment Rights

Just hours after Election Day, anti-gun lawmakers in Arizona are already signaling plans to pursue gun control in 2027, leaving law-abiding Arizonans to face the harsh reality that a consequential legislative session lies ahead.  

Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

Friday, November 13, 2026

Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

The election is over, but national gun control groups are already setting their sights on Nevadan's Second Amendment rights.   

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.