Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

The Prosecutors and the Pagans: Two Sides of the Empire State’s Gun Laws

Friday, April 21, 2017

The Prosecutors and the Pagans: Two Sides of the Empire State’s Gun Laws

Early this month, members of the gun-control group Prosecutors Against Gun Violence met at a “Manhattan Summit” and took the time to express their dismay and alarm over federal bills proposing national concealed carry reciprocity. At the group’s news conference, Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr., explained that if the “dangerous” reciprocity legislation passes, someone from neighboring Vermont, “where there are no permit requirements, could come into New York City with a loaded gun, come to Times Square, go to the subways and be amongst us in our communities.” This would be very bad, apparently, despite the fact that Vermont consistently ranks as one of the safest states in the country, with a violent crime rate less than a third of that of New York State and where an estimated 70 to 75 percent of adult Vermonters own guns. 

In addition to this spectre of “subways packed with pistols or shootouts in Times Square,” other New Yorkers at the April 4th event added their own dire predictions that the federal legislation would “open the floodgates of people packing firearms on City streets,” with “the flood of guns pos[ing] a serious risk to our families,” and leading to “bloodshed in our communities.” All of these top law enforcement officials stressed the need to keep communities safe and the importance of local gun laws that protect the public.

This extravagant rhetoric rings hollow when considered in the context of a New York State lawsuit, a real-life study on how some of these “sensible” laws apparently work in safeguarding members of the public. 

The plaintiff, Sean McCarthy, is a resident of Suffolk County who applied for an unrestricted (“full carry”) license to carry a concealed weapon in 2015. New York State is a “may issue” state, and a person seeking an unrestricted license for the purpose of self-protection must establish, among other things, that “proper cause” exists, pursuant to N.Y. Penal Law § 400.00 Sub. 2(f). State law mandates an investigation of a license application to ensure that all statements are true, and the licensing officer may deny the application if “good cause exists for the denial of the license.”

Based on the complaint in the lawsuit, the licensing authority, the Commissioner of the Suffolk County Police Department, and various named officers, denied McCarthy’s application almost a year later, with the investigator’s response stating that while the application was made on the basis of McCarthy’s reason to fear for his personal safety, “the Applicant failed to establish proper cause for a full carry endorsement.” (She did, however, recommend that a restricted “sportsman license” be granted.) According to McCarthy, the letter rejecting his application advised that for an unrestricted license, he had to show that he was “exposed to extraordinary personal danger, documented by proof of recurrent threats to life or safety.” That’s when things get interesting.

As outlined in his complaint, in the late 1990s McCarthy had been a manager and doorman at a “gentlemen’s club” in Suffolk County called The Carousel. During his employment, McCarthy had banned members of the Pagan Outlaws motorcycle gang from the premises after he learned that the Pagans were attempting to extort “protection money” from the owners and other club employees. According to him, the Pagans responded with several violent attacks in an effort to intimidate him, including an unprovoked assault at the club in which seven gang members almost killed McCarthy by beating, kicking and stabbing him. Police were called, but to date “ha[d] not made a single arrest of any person who participated” in this attack. After this incident, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) contacted McCarthy to confirm that their undercover surveillance of the Pagans revealed McCarthy’s life was in danger. Pagan members who had been apprehended in the course of this federal investigation were found to have personal information about McCarthy and maps to his home. By late 1997, when the local leader of the Pagans was arrested, the attempted murder charges in the federal criminal complaint against him arose out of the “contract” that he had put out on McCarthy. Other arrests followed, and McCarthy alleges he was a “key, indispensable witness” in these proceedings, which lead to convictions of the local leader and many others, with lengthy prison sentences.

These criminals have been or will soon be released and returning to Suffolk County, and possibly resuming their former lifestyle in the same community as Sean McCarthy.

McCarthy’s application for an unrestricted license included this information in support of his claim of an actual need for self-defense. Nonetheless, the denial of an unrestricted license was confirmed and sustained by the Suffolk Police Department – a denial based, according to McCarthy, in a failure of the proper officials to consult the FBI, other relevant law enforcement officials, and their own police department records regarding McCarthy’s history and circumstances. 

If Sean McCarthy’s allegations are correct, there is likely no better indication of the senselessness of New York State’s restrictive concealed carry weapons permitting law. 

We can all agree on the importance of public safety and the welfare of the community. While it’s well and good to speak out for laws that prevent gun violence, there’s little justification for attacking legislation simply because it allows “more guns,” and even less reason to defend legislation that strips law-abiding citizens of their right to defend themselves.

TRENDING NOW
DHS “Misinformation Governance Board” Could Seek to Sway Gun Debate

News  

Monday, May 16, 2022

DHS “Misinformation Governance Board” Could Seek to Sway Gun Debate

In late April, Alejandro Mayorkas, Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), made a bizarre announcement during a congressional hearing that DHS was forming what it called a “Mis- and Disinformation Governance Board.” The statement came ...

Follow the Science, Unless it Leads Where You Don’t Want to Go

News  

Monday, May 16, 2022

Follow the Science, Unless it Leads Where You Don’t Want to Go

Researchers in California have published the results of a study evaluating the effectiveness of so-called “gun violence restraining orders” (a.k.a. “extreme risk protection orders” or “red flag” orders). Assembly Bill 1014, was enacted in California in ...

NRA Achieves Historical Milestone as 25 States Recognize Constitutional Carry

News  

Friday, April 1, 2022

NRA Achieves Historical Milestone as 25 States Recognize Constitutional Carry

Half the country will now enjoy the freedom to carry a handgun for self-defense without a permit from the state thanks to the tireless efforts of men and women of the National Rifle Association. 

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

Gun Laws  

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

CAUTION: Federal and state firearms laws are subject to frequent change. This summary is not to be considered as legal advice or a restatement of law.

NRA-ILA Spring 2022 Litigation Newsletter

News  

Friday, May 13, 2022

NRA-ILA Spring 2022 Litigation Newsletter

NRA-ILA’s Office of Litigation Counsel has been busy fighting for our members’ rights in courtrooms across the country. ILA has filed new cases, continued the fight in many existing cases, and scored some good wins. ...

Illinois: General Assembly Passes “Ghost Gun” Ban

Monday, April 11, 2022

Illinois: General Assembly Passes “Ghost Gun” Ban

On Friday, the House Judiciary Committee held a subject matter hearing on House Bill 4383 Senate Floor Amendment 2, to ban individuals from making their own firearms for personal use, and voted to advance the measure. ...

Grassroots Spotlight: Remembering Michael Omatsu

Wednesday, May 11, 2022

Grassroots Spotlight: Remembering Michael Omatsu

The term "I am the NRA" speaks truth and strength to those special NRA members that choose to be strong advocates in their communities. Michael Omatsu was a passionate NRA-ILA FrontLines Activist Leader (FAL) who went ...

Georgia: Gov. Kemp Signs Constitutional Carry

Tuesday, April 12, 2022

Georgia: Gov. Kemp Signs Constitutional Carry

Today, Governor Brian Kemp signed Senate Bill 319, constitutional carry, into law. Georgia is now the 25th constitutional carry state, and the fourth to join that group in 2022. Half of the country now recognizes the right ...

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

Gun Laws  

Monday, June 30, 2014

Guide To The Interstate Transportation Of Firearms

CAUTION: Federal and state firearms laws are subject to frequent change. This summary is not to be considered as legal advice or a restatement of law.

President Donald J. Trump to Address NRA Members at the 2022 NRA Annual Meetings and Exhibits in Houston, Texas

News  

Thursday, May 12, 2022

President Donald J. Trump to Address NRA Members at the 2022 NRA Annual Meetings and Exhibits in Houston, Texas

Former President Donald J. Trump will headline the 2022 NRA-ILA Leadership Forum on May 27, at the George R. Brown Convention Center in Houston.

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.